Monday, September 24, 2007

Synthesis

As technology continues to advance, computers become more and more apart of everyones' lives. Computer provide fast information in a convenient and easy process. Stoll believes that a computer cannot replace books or a convincing teacher. Ohman also believes that computers are overrated for the classroom, but takes a separate viewpoint of Stoll. Ohman focuses more so on the business aspect and the industry forcing the sale of computers on school systems.
Stoll tells us that computers feed the user nonsense and entertainment instead of providing an alternative research method. He is convinced that computer are no more helpful than the nonsense involved in filmstrips. He sees both technological advancements "of dubious educational value." He believes learning does not take place through technology but through interaction of student and teacher. Stoll also presents the idea that plagarism is easier with computers. It shows students to use a "copy-and-paste attitude" when approaching research and papers. Stoll cannot accept the new wave, or should I say, present wave of technology, because he believes teachers are the only adequete way to get information to the youth. Richard Ohman feels the same way as Stoll does about computers, but not for the same reasons. He believes the integration of the computer is due to "expansionism on the part of capital." More or less, technology is being pushed onto schools across the country due to the profit in big business. The consumer continues to comply with technological demands, and big businesses around the world profit from a so-called 'school necessity.' He shares Stoll's opinion that computers are more of a distraction in class than a benefit.
Unfortunately for these two gentlemen, computers are going to be apart of schooling from here on out. And whether you hate it or love it, everyone should learn to embrace it. Computers, for the expenses and confusion that they cause, truly do have benefits in a students work environment. Internet and email makes communication extremely simple. Not only can a student contact their teacher at any time, but parents have the opportunity to contact an elementary school teacher when necessary. Computers also ready students for the real world. Most jobs in the world today are becoming computer-based and a student should understand the technology necessary for their life. These are life skills that should be developed early on. Information has also become more readily available due to the advancement of the internet. Students are able to cite sources much more easily than sitting in a library and searching through hundreds of books. Computers may be a distraction, but either way they are here to stay.

No comments: